Forum:Counsellor Challenges

   Forums: Index >

 [ View recent changes for this forum]



This is where you can issue challenges for Counsellor and Lieutenant Counsellor positions in a cabin. There are a few rules and things to note:

Rules/Etc.
Rules=

Rules
Scoring=
 * 1) In the case of the Head Counsellor or Lieutenant Counsellor having led no quests, no led quests are required to challenge.
 * 2) In the case of a Head or Lieutenant Counsellor having led one or more quests, the challenger is required to have led at least one successful quest. You only need one quest though.
 * 3) A User is required to have a user level of 4 or higher to challenge for a counselor position.
 * 4) The challenger is responsible for leaving a notice, both on the character page of the current counsellor, and the cabin page, that they are challenging, and what position they are challenging for, as well as messaging the user OOC on their talk page. (So in three places).
 * 5) Once the challenger has left a notice, they need to make a forum for the challenge
 * 6) Fights will be conducted in the same way as training fights, meaning the combatants will take turns posting their actions and reactions to each others attacks
 * 7) The winner will be decided by two judges. These judges will be assigned, once the challenge is ready to be judged.
 * 8) You will be judged not only by the outcome of the fight, but by roleplay quality, attitude, realism, and other factors
 * 9) If the current counsellor does not respond within a week to the challenging posts made by the challenger, they are considered to forfeit the fight, and must surrender their position to the challenger. The challenger must be able to show proof, that a notice was left in all of the appropriate places.
 * 10) Fights will proceed thusly: The challenger will post first. They have one post to describe themselves, talk about their battle preparations, brag, or what have you. The counsellor will then have one post to do the same. Then, battle will commence.
 * 11) Battles will last ten rounds. This is ten posts from each character, excluding the general discussion posts (which should be done with word bubbles) and OOC posts.
 * 12) After the allotted ten rounds, each char will have one post to "end the fight" with. Whether this be ended by some kind of bell, or by the fight ending, or something else, is up to them.
 * 13) Users must put their character's name next to the action. Like this Tsumi
 * 14) When the fight is over, please move the page to the 'ready to be judged' category, so that it can be dealt with quickly.
 * 15) Godmodding or metagaming will automatically disqualify a character, if done to an excessive degree, otherwise 1 or 2 minor instances of it will just get points taken off
 * 16) If one of the contestants does not reply within 7 days, they lose the challenge automatically. Exceptions are given for users with Away Notices.
 * 17) A user cannot be challenged for a position within a month of getting it. If someone got the position by default, because someone left the wiki or got rid of their character, it doesn't count.

Scoring

 * Grammar/Spelling - 5 points
 * Posts should use correct grammar and spelling, within reason.


 * Defensive - 10 points
 * How well the character defends themselves


 * Offensive - 10 points
 * How well the character attacks


 * Fairness - 20 points
 * How fair the characters are as far as taking hits.


 * Balance - 10 points
 * This is the overall balance between offensive and defensive moves, as well as between regular weapons versus their powers.


 * Strategy - 5 points
 * This is for how overall prepared the characters seem and whether or not they are considering the best defensive and offensive moves available to them.


 * Creativity - 15 points
 * This is how creative the users are with their moves.


 * Effective Char Use - 20 points
 * This is for whether the character is using all means available to them, not just weapons, but terrain and their powers.


 * Judge's Discretion - 5 points
 * This is for how the judges feel the user did overall, this should not be used for any personal bias or feelings.

Challenging an Outcome=

Challenging an Outcome
If you feel after a challenge is completed that one or both of the judges were either biased in their scores or generally unfair in their judgement, you may challenge the outcome. At which point 3 unbiased (unbiased in that they were neither the original judge or involved in the challenge itself) to look over the challenge and either vote fair or unfair. If the consensus from the 3 is that the challenge was fair, it will stand as is. If the consensus is the challenge was voted unfairly, it will be re-scored. The outcome is not guaranteed to call a new winner, but the person who lost may lose by less and have a better idea of what area they need to work on for next time they try a challenge. Arenas=

Arenas
If you would like to use one of these arenas, just add the template to the challenge page.

Challenges
Unprocessed=

Unprocessed
Ready to be Judged=

Ready to be Judged
In Process=

Challenge in Process
Forfeits=

Forfeits
No Contest=

No Contest
Completed=

Counsellor List/Counts
(i) = Officially Less Active

Updated by Bach 12/24/2012

See this discussion about Lt/Head spots (12/24/2012)

By Cabin
(Leading) = they are leading one but it's still on-going

Yes = the quest they led is over and made it past camp and at least through 1 monster attack

Blank = No quests led or leading